Garmin Montana 700 Review Garmin Instinct Solar Review

Garmin! Which satellite systems should I use? GPS, GLONASS, GALILEO?

The combination of GPS & GLONASS or GPS & GALILEO satellite systems has established itself as a standard for many outdoor & bicyle devices and wearables. Positioning with the help of two GNSS*  has its advantages.

The availability of two systems means that more satellites are available. This can have an impact on the time to first positioning and the positioning accuracy.

* Global Navigation Satellite System

How many GPS, GLONASS & GALILEO satellites are available?

(status: January 2020)

  • GPS: 29 operational satellites
  • GLONASS: 23 operational satellites
  • GALILEO: 22 operational satellites (the full operational constellation of 24 satellites is expected to be available in 2020)

Information on the current statuses can be found here:

What are the advantages of using two satellite systems simultaneously?

A good example is shown in the figure. Due to the availability of only four GPS satellites and an unfavourable satellite geometry in a mountain valley (three out of four GPS satellites are in a row), the position determination is relatively inaccurate. The accuracy is shown as "25 m".

The same applies to large cities. High buildings ("urban canyons") can also cause shadows effects, there are fewer satellites in the direct field of view of the GPS receiver.

In addition, "multipathing" effects often occur in mountains and cities due to reflected satellite signals, also resulting in poorer accuracy.

GPS only, bad satellite constellation and accuracy

What positive effect has a second GNSS?

More satellites distributed over the sky can lead to a more favourable distribution ("geometry") and thus to a better accuracy and a faster positioning.

Garmin defines GPS accuracy as follows:

Accuracy of the position in m (CEP, Circular Error Probable: 50% of all measurements are within the specified radius (e.g. 25 m), 50% of all measurements are outside of this radius).

Another note: At least three satellites are required to determine the position, and at least four satellites must be in use to determine the GPS altitude.

What are the disadvantages of using GPS, GLONASS and GALILEO simultaneously?

The disadvantage is the slightly increased power consumption of the GPS receivers, in my experience it is about 10% (GPS handhelds like Garmin Oregon or eTrex). With wearables it can look different, because they rather have "power saving" chips.

Figures (screenshots Garmin eTrex 32x): Excellent satellite reception; GPS + GLONASS (left) does not lead to a better accuracy compared to GPS only. The accuracy is always 3 m. GPS: 02 – 30, GLONASS: 68 – 84.

eTrex 32x: GPS and GLONASS satellites
eTrex 32x: GPS satellites

Garmin – GPS only, GPS & GLONASS or GPS & GALILEO – What do you recommend?

Our recommendation is to deactivate GLONASS or GALILEO if possible (most handheld devices supports this) and to use GPS only; switch a second GNSS on when necessary (mountains, cities, forests with a high tree density).

Garmin devices allow these GNSS combinations:

  • GPS
  • GPS + GLONASS (currently the standard for GPS devices from Garmin)
  • GPS + GALILEO (GALILEO is recommended when fully operational in 2020)

significant increase in accuracy should be expected when chips supporting multiple GNSS and multiple frequencies are used in the future. An example is the Broadcom BCM47755 chip that can use GPS, GLONASS, BeiDou (the Chinese GNSS), QZSS (the Japanese GNSS) and GALILEO as well as two frequencies (L1+L5).

Exciting news – Garmin released new Multiband-GNSS handhelds

Garmin announced three GPSMAP handhelds providing multi-band (L1 & L5) and multi-GNSS technology for a better accuracy in challenging environments!

Read: Garmin – GPSMAP 66sr & GPSMAP 65 Series

The situation is different for wearables

For example, when you run, the wearable is attached to another dynamic system: your moving arm. The GPS antenna usually points somehow to the side and not skywards, your body causes shadowing when receiving satellite signals. All these factors can lead to GPS inaccuracies.

Therefore, it is better to get the maximum out of it by using GPS + GLONASS – this setting is also the Garmin standard for wearables and is continuosly optimized.

Must readGarmin fenix GPS accuracy

Note: The articles may contain affiliate links. If you buy through these links I will receive a commission; thus you support the continuation of this website. There are no additional costs for you. It is up to you where and when you buy a product. I do not receive any information about the buyer.

Leave a Comment

5 thoughts on “Garmin! Which satellite systems should I use? GPS, GLONASS, GALILEO?”

  1. I have a garmin 945 watch. Until now I used polar vantage and I had no problems with gps.
    When registering a known route with a garmin watch, I was surprised that it is shorter than usually recorded with various watches or telephones, and the "actual tempo" indicator always shows a much lower pace than I actually run.
    I did various tests for several weeks and I have such observations.
    – In Europe (Poland) the GPS + Galileo configuration works best on a garmin watch
    .
    – GPS + Glonass works best on Polar
    .
    – When I set gps + glonass on my garmin watch, the accuracy of measurements decreases drastically.
    – When I run with two watches, the distance is the same on both only when set (gps + glonass on polar) and (gps + galileo on garmin)
    .
    I wonder if one of these watches has a naming error and if by chance in a garmin watch gps + galileo mode is not really glonass.
    Do you know how to check this?
    Changing the registration from "smart" to "every seconds" did not improve the measurement accuracy very much.
    What do you think about it, what are your opinions?

    Reply
    • Hi Michael,

      I do not believe that the Garmin wearables have a naming error – however, I do not know how to check which satellite systems are in use as the Garmin wearables have no NMEA output (except the quatix) or a satellite page.

      My standard for the fenix is GPS + GLONASS as I want to compare it with other devices like the Polar GRIT X (Polar recommends GPS + GLONASS as default and has no option for "GPS only"), and I think it is generally better to use a wearable with two GNSS.

      The data recording has no impact on GPS accuracy, because you change only the algorithm for recording and not the GPS frequency.

      Cheers!

      Reply
      • Hi, i úsed fenix 5+, testing in Hanoi, Vietnam. Gps only, gps + glonass , and gps + galileo , it is cloudy and raining condition. Result of gps +galileo showing more accurate than the others. Cheers

        Reply
  2. My Garmin 1000 doesn’t stay "fixed" on map mode, even when I push on the map + to expand. Any idea on how to correct this? It’s aggravating when I am out in the middle of the woods and trying to figure the road to take…(I care a paper map of the areas that I travel)

    Reply
    • Hi,
      what do you say? Does the position of the position marker changes continuously (can be a normal behaviour depending on the GPS signals)) or is the map moving even if stationary (sounds strange)?
      Cheers

      Reply

Note: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!